REVIEW: The Waiting City

Wednesday, October 21, 2009 at 10:15 pm

This is the fifteenth film I saw at the 14th Pusan International Film Festival.

An Australian film set entirely in Calcutta (now Kolkata), India, starring the awesome Radha Mitchell (who also produces) and the low-key Joel Edgerton (you may remember him from Kinky Boots). A relationship drama about a pair of Australian husband and wife who descend upon India to collect the Indian orphan baby they have adopted, only to be set back by bureaucracy – which begins to test their relationship as it gradually exposes their problems the way low tide reveals previously hidden beach rocks.

It sounds dramatically plain, which is why I almost never saw it (it wasn't on my schedule of movies until fairly last minute), and even then I only saw it because I read that Mitchell and Edgerton are in it. But it's a beautifully realised film - the relationship stuff is nuanced and affecting (thanks to both direction and acting), and the drama is strong and never a false note – never a moment of false melodrama. In other words, the relationship problems were, like real ones, at once simple and complex. The interaction between husband and wife thus feels real, indicating a highly matured guiding hand behind the film.

The husband and wife also don't come across as just a pair of inconsiderate, whiny Westerners wandering noisily through exotic India, though whine they do and exotic as the Indian settings are. The wife also seems to undergo a transcending, meditative experience as she begins to get to know India and its people, while the husband can only relate to it all through his New Age-y knowledge of such things.

Transformers girl Isabel Lucas is here as well in a small role that functions just to irritate the wife about her husband.

What I was most impressed with was the cinematography – in particular, the look of the images, which looks crisp and clear with a colour tone that is at once muted and saturated (not sure how to describe it). It is such a shame that there isn't a Q&A, because I would really like to ask director Claire McCarthy what film stock she used to shoot the movie. (McCarthy was in fact present in Pusan, and came onstage before the film began to introduce it, but she said that she was told there wasn't enough time to do a Q&A session after. I wished she had hung around after the film.) DP is Denson Baker.

Another element worth pointing out for praise is the score by Michael Yezerski, which is appropriately poignant and ethereal and easily puts us in a state to observe the characters and sometimes to enter their emotional state.

Did I Like It? Yeah, liked it enough.
Did I Fall Asleep? Nearly did at a couple of points.

-----------------

4 comments

  1. souljhol Says:

    It was shot on RED cameras in digital. Did you not feel that the images were a bit flat on the big screen ?

  2. McGarmott Says:

    Well, I'm not a DP (and don't have the eye or the talent to ever be one) ... But I just really liked the look to it. Maybe flat is good?

  3. Denson Says:

    It was shot on RED cameras with Cooke S4 Lenses, graded in a Lustre suite at EFilm in Sydney then printed back to 35mm, it was certainly never intended to look flat.

    We also tested many different filters to create a look that was more organic and less digital and I was very pleased with the final image.

    I think soft lighting makes a big difference too.

    Thank you for your nice remarks, I am glad you liked the cinematogs!

    Regards

    Denson Baker ACS
    Director of Photography
    www.densonbaker.com

  4. McGarmott Says:

    Cheers for the explanation, mate! Would certainly like to pick your brains on specific shots if I ever get a chance to sit down and chat with you.

Cinematic Concerns | Powered by Blogger | Entries (RSS) | Comments (RSS) | Designed by MB Web Design | XML Coded By Cahayabiru.com